The Shatzkin Files


Ruth Cavin, great editor and world’s nicest person, gone at 92


The title of “nicest person on the planet” is now open. The longtime incumbent, Ruth Cavin — also a veteran book editor who was known to many as the doyenne of mysteries — died early Sunday morning at the age of 92. She was still holding down a full time position as an editor with the Thomas Dunne Books imprint at St. Martin’s at her death.

What is unique about Ruth’s career is that she didn’t become an editor until she was past her 60th birthday and didn’t start her more than two decades at St. Martin’s until she was 70. She was sort of the Grandma Moses of mystery editors.

I had the very good fortune to have known Ruth all my life.

Ruth Brodie grew up in Pittsburgh where she first met my mother, Eleanor Oshry, when they went to kindergarten together. They were active together as schoolchildren in the YPSLs (Young People’s Socialist League, the youth arm of the political party that was led by Norman Thomas) and they both attended college locally at Carnegie Tech (now Carnegie-Mellon).

The story in the family is that when my father, Leonard Shatzkin, went out to Tech in 1938 to get his degree in printing, he had the phone number of two girls in his pocket: my Mom and Ruth. He called Mom first. She said she knew he had both numbers, so she kept him too busy from that point on to have time to call Ruth.

But they all became friends and worked together on the Carnegic Tartan, the school paper, on which Ruth was a columnist, Dad eventually the editor, and Mom the managing editor.

I realize as I write this that I never asked Ruth exactly how she ended up in New York after college. What I do know is that between when the war ended, during which my Dad had been exempted from service because he was working on the Manhattan Project, and when my arrival could be anticipated (which would have been late in 1946), they thought he would be drafted. My parents organized a going-away party for him for which the guests were all married couples except for two single friends: Ruth and a young Business Week writer named Bram Cavin.

The families remained close, personally and professionally. When Dad started the Dolphin Books imprint at Doubleday, he was able to hire Bram as an editor. In the early 1960s, the Cavins with their young children, son Tony and twin daughters Emily and Nora, moved to Pleasantville near where we lived in Croton and we saw them increasingly often. They moved to Cleveland in about 1964 when Bram took a job as an editor with World Publishing and Ruth’s home was my stop the first night I was driving across the country to go to UCLA in 1965.

Ruth was not working full time then but was active in anti-war politics. She was also interested in whatever you were interested in. I remember in the late 60s when bands starting putting out “concept” albums sitting with her for an hour with the Moody Blues’ “Days of Future Passed”, talking about what was “different” about all this, or whether anything really was.

In the early 1970s, my father started The Two Continents Publishing Group, setting up a trade book distributor on what is now the PGW-NBN model before there really any prototypes. Dad hired Ruth as his first employee to do the publicity. She also sold the subsidiary rights. I got the entirely-too-inflated title of Director of Marketing which meant that I got credit for a lot of what Ruth did.

Her output was prodigious. She wrote all the catalog copy, edited or wrote press releases, flap copy, and rep information for what grew into many dozens of books a year. She called on all the book clubs and all the senior book reviewers. Meanwhile, she had written a couple of books. One was called “Dinners for Beginners”. Another was on inter-urban rail transportation, mostly in the midwest, called “Trolleys.”

And, I must stress, it would be an understatement to say she had a smile on her face every day. Ruth had a smile on her face every minute. Nothing flustered or annoyed her. When you knew her well, you knew she had smiled her way through some pretty significant annoyances. She had a mastectomy in 1941. (She told me about two years ago that she now thinks she didn’t have cancer; that the diagnosis was a mistake.) She had a pacemaker installed in the late 1960s. I’ll bet that very few people who knew her had any idea about either of these things.

When the Shatzkins sold out of Two Continents in 1979, Ruth was 61 but definitely not done working. She was looking for new worlds to conquer. She managed to get a job at Walker and Company, a family-owned independent publisher that did a lot of mysteries. And thus did Ruth become a mystery editor.

Among the people she worked with at Walker were Philip Turner, who went on to work at Random House, Kodansha, and Sterling, and David Sobel, later at Wiley and Holt. I had an exchange with David yesterday in which he said, tongue only partly in cheek, that Ruth taught him everything he knows.

Ruth would teach you without it feeling like teaching. Every conversation was with an equal; every relationship was collegial. Her respect for other people was universal and deep and entirely genuine.

Tom Dunne was the man who “discovered” Ruth (when she was 70) for his imprint but he had support for the idea from then-CEO Tom McCormack. McCormack (another Doubleday alumnus originally recruited by my father) told me that he had a previous good experience with Joan Kahn, a mystery editor who had been retired by Harper at age 65 and then gave St. Martin’s ten great years.

Ruth started five years older and gave them more than 20!

The enormous productivity that my family and I saw in Ruth at Two Continents continued to be her reputation at St. Martin’s. I heard over the years that she routinely acquired, edited, and put into production more books than anybody. Since I pitched a few and sold her a couple over that time, I can tell you that she did all that without stinting on any part of the job from first contact through contract and editing and launch. Working with her was a positive experience for every author I know who did it.

With greater diligence since my Mom died in 2007, I’d see Ruth every few months outside the holiday season. We’d have lunch. She’d come along to see my nephew A.J. Shively in a play. I took her downtown a couple of times to get new hearing aids. I could see her decline. The scoliosis in her spine had her bent over so her back was nearly parallel to the ground. That meant she couldn’t breathe. We’d have to stop 3 times on the one block walk from her office to the restaurant she frequented.

Her memory, which, for names, had been sliding for years, started showing other lapses. I’d always ask her about her job. She always had a determination to keep it; the time she spent in the office with her colleagues was precious to her. A couple of years ago, she told me a bit abashedly that her company had insisted she stop taking the bus down from Grand Central to the office and provided her with a cab and then a car to take her back at the end of the day. (This was at the time that Bram was in a home near the White Plains train station, and Ruth stopped and saw him every evening on the way home.) A year or so ago, she said there was a plan afoot to have her work at home sometimes because the travel to the office was exhausting her. But she loved being with her colleagues. And she revered her boss, Tom Dunne, who really was the one who gave her this magnificent post-retirement-age career.

I had a conversation with St. Martin’s Publisher Sally Richardson (Dunne’s boss) about Ruth at a party for Al Silverman’s book three years ago. Sally was saying that she was working on making sure Ruth got a decent winter coat; she was so frugal and unconcerned with her own comfort that Sally had to, more or less, do it for her.

I told a few people at Macmillan that I wanted to acknowledge them publicly on Ruth’s behalf for the extraordinary sensitivity and generosity they showed her over the last months, perhaps even years, of her life. Although Tom McCormack made the point that they had learned that a “no age limit” policy made sense through their experience decades ago with Joan Kahn, that policy would not have obliged them to give her the extra support and reduced expectations that she must have required in the recent past.

They did that because they loved her, which was an inevitable consequence of knowing her well, so that isn’t extraordinary. But the fact that the company, particularly a company of the size of Macmillan, treated her better than many families would, is both rare and worthy of commendation. From this lifelong friend of Ruth’s, thanks very much.

  Back to blog

  • Tracy Y

    Mike, I love these pieces about people, and not only because I understand them better than the business stories ;) You have a real gift for appreciating people.
    I know you're not old enough yet, but there is an amazing memoir waiting to be written.

    • /blog Mike Shatzkin

      Thanks, Tracy. As one of the people I really appreciate and who would have

      star turns in several chapters of the memoir, I'll take your point under

      advisement!

      Mike

      • Eugene Schwartz

        I second the motion about the memoir. You do have a great gift for bringing people and the industry past alive – from the trenches and the heart. And as one of your early prospects for Two Contiinents when you were making sales calls — I remmber when-

        Gene

      • /blog Mike Shatzkin

        I see you and Tracy have a couple of years of my life planned out for me! I

        think the memoir will actually have to be written 1500 words at a time on

        the blog.

        Mike

  • Bill Crider

    Ruth was my first editor, in 1986, and was still my editor until yesterday. What a great person she was, and what a great life. Thanks for this post.

    • /blog Mike Shatzkin

      Thanks for saying so. We'll always remember her.

      Mike

  • Christina Harcar

    Mike, I'm sorry for your loss, for SMP's loss, and for the Mystery community — thank you for this very heartfelt post and for your acknowledgment of Tom Dunne, Sally Richardson et al. (whose kindnesses often go unremarked.)

    When I think of Ruth, I know this is a sad day for her publishing family and her actual family, but I also feel so lucky to have known her and worked with her…

    • /blog Mike Shatzkin

      Yes, we were lucky to have known her, and she'd want us to remember that SHE

      was lucky to have lived such a long time and to have been allowed to be

      productive for just about all of it!

      Mike

  • Vicky

    I've worked with Ruth Cavin since 1988 or 1989 when she bought NEW ORLEANS MOURNING by Julie Smith, which she published in 1990 and which went on to win the Edgar for Best Novel. I believe that Julie was the first American woman to win an Edgar for Best Novel since the 1950s. The book is still in print and is a wonderful testimony to Ruth's great eye and great taste.

    • /blog Mike Shatzkin

      Thanks, Vicky. I don't think Julie or Ruth even remembered then that I had

      shown Ruth a first effort by Julie as a mystery writer back in the 1970s!

      Ruth wasn't the mystery doyenne then and Julie was still a journalist at the

      San Francisco Chronicle. I'm so glad they got to collaborate under your

      auspices a decade later.

      Mike

  • Jeffrey Capshew

    Thanks Mike, what a wonderful tribute. I learned more about Ruth reading this from you.
    I will miss her a lot.

    • /blog Mike Shatzkin

      Ruth was a very modest person, Jeff. I'm not surprised a lot of what I said

      was new to people who worked with her for years, as you did. Congratulations

      on being part of a company with such a big heart.

      Mike

  • Philipsturner

    I had the good fortune of seeing Ruth and Nora in late December at Tom Dunne's year-end office party. As I passed by one of those small Flatiron Bldg. offices, I peeked in and saw Ruth with Nora, enjoying the party but away from the fray. I happily tucked in with them and spent a delightful twenty minutes, reminiscing about days gone by and talking about some of the books in her office, some mysteries I'd recently read, and books I've been working on. It was a sweet reunion and I believe really tender for all three of us.

    One thing Mike referred to that I can confirm in spades: Ruth was not only an extremely hard-working editor, she was extremely efficient. Like an experienced laborer–who can dig a ditch without strain, and more quickly than any others nearby–Ruth just mowed down the manuscripts when we were together at Walker. What's more, she seemed oblivious to distraction, and always kept editing without a hitch, even while she remained an eager colleague, one with whom you could always discuss a news story or a new book.

    Macmillan did exhibit exemplary conduct in keeping her on board as they did. My sympathies to Nora and all her family members.

    • /blog Mike Shatzkin

      Thanks, Phil. And thanks for the confirmation of her editing skill from

      somebody who has considerable cred in that domain himself!

      Mike

  • Pingback: Tweets that mention Ruth Cavin, great editor and world’s nicest person, gone at 92 – The Shatzkin Files -- Topsy.com

  • Jackie Cantor

    I met Ruth years ago when she worked at Walker. She was a wonder: unflappable, as you point out, unfailingly kind, exceptionally smart, and merry as the day is long. (She had the world's greatest laugh.) Also a demon with the New York Times crossword puzzle, which she did daily and completed flawlessly. I loved her. My deepest condolences to her family and to her colleagues at St. Martin's.

    • /blog Mike Shatzkin

      She had a great laugh and she displayed it with wonderful frequency.

      Mike

  • Steven Rosato

    My most sincere condolences to you and all those that were close to Ruth. Your tribute was wonderfully written, providing inspiration from a life well lived.

    • /blog Mike Shatzkin

      Thanks, Steve. We're sad to lose her, but she didn't get cheated. Ninety-two

      years and fully employed at the end is something we can all aspire to!

      Mike

  • Maureen Walters

    Maureen Walters
    When I think of Ruth I always find myself smiling. She was a grand lady who I met when I was just starting out as an agent and she was a editor at Walker. I had always loved mysteries so we had much to talk about but in addition, she taught me so much about publishing in general. I always loved Tom Dunne for hiring Ruth. She will be sorely missed.

    • /blog Mike Shatzkin

      I can tell you for absolute certain that Ruth herself would be very pleased

      to know that the thought of her makes you smile. And I've got a big grin on

      as I write this reply to you!

      Mike

  • Katie

    Thank you for this beautiful tribute to Ruth. My mother, Frances Scott, (who passed away last February) also went to Carnegie Tech with Ruth, and moved to the NYC after college. (seeking their fortunes! – probably more like it was an exciting place to be for young creatives/artists…) I think they were roommates for a time.

    Ruth and Frances continued their friendship through the years: meeting for lunch in the city, or going to Yale plays on Saturday nights with Beverly Wallace, and other friends. When my mother was slowing down, and could no longer travel, Ruth, Beverly and Nora would regularly visit her Nyack, bringing lunch goodies and good company. Ruth's “world's nicest person” status certainly extended to the friendships she maintained. (And a huge thank you to Nora, for facilitating those trips in recent years!)

    The story I love about Ruth's eye, or in this case ear, for good work started one day when she was listening to a program on NPR called “The Splendid Table”. A man called in to the show to ask advice on getting his idea into print. He received some advice, however, he was soon to find out that it was his very lucky day! Ruth heard something in his idea, got his contact info from the station, asked for a book proposal, and proceeded to edit: Artisan Bread in Five Minutes a Day: The Discovery That Revolutionizes Home Baking – (which, by the way, has a 4.5 star rating on Amazon – with over 700 reviews..)

    We'll miss you, Ruth!

    • /blog Mike Shatzkin

      Katie, I met your mother through Ruth back in the day. I know they were good

      friends and, I think, creative collaborators. Beverly joins the crowd at our

      house for the November and December holidays so she also got to see Ruth two

      last times in the weeks just before she died. Thanks for adding these

      thoughts.

      Mike

      • Katie

        Mike,
        You are correct – in 1973 Ruth authored, and my mom illustrated “1 Pinch of Sunshine, 1/2 cup of Rain (Natural Food Recipes for Young People)” On the back flap bio of Ruth it says: “Ruth Cavin maintains that a free-lance writing career can teach a person more about different kinds of subjects than a university education…. Her two teen-age daughters say she's taught them to cook; she wasn't aware that it was happening at the time….” Fun tidbits.

        So nice to celebrate Ruth by reading and sharing all the gems!
        Thanks again.

      • /blog Mike Shatzkin

        Wow. A natural foods receipe book in 1973! Your mom and Ruth were quite a

        bit ahead of their time. And since Ruth had both a freelance writing career

        *and *a university education, she had the cred to back up her comment!

        Mike

    • Zoe

      Hi Katie,

      We are indeed so very grateful that Ruth was listening to the radio that fortuitous day. She took a huge risk on our book, when no one else would and we are so very, very lucky that she did. Artisan Bread in Five Minutes a Day would never have been published if she had not pushed for it. It would not be the success that it is without her wonderful editing skills. Cheers to her courageous, risk taking spirit and profound generosity. She will be missed!

      Mike, thank you for this outstanding remembrance of Ruth, she was even more remarkable than I even knew!

      Zoë François (co-author Artisan Bread in Five a Day)

      • /blog Mike Shatzkin

        The good news and the bad news is that Ruth told me the story of Artisan

        Bread (without names, she was past remembering names) several times over the

        past few years. And I can say with absolute authority that Ruth would be

        chuckling along with us if she read this. Her ability to see humor in

        situations never diminished.

        Mike

      • Katie

        Hi Zoe,
        Not only did Ruth choose and edit your book, she sold it!
        She told its story so delightfully, that every one of us at the gathering wanted a copy – and I'm not a baker at all! Knowing the story of it, made your book even more delicious! So glad it has been so successful! A serendipitous day on the radio for sure! Thanks to Ruth for brightening our lives.
        Cheers!
        Katie

  • Gerrie Ferris Finger

    I read your tribute with great interest and joy. Ruth chose my novel, THE END GAME, as the 2009 St. Martin's/Malice Best First Traditional Mystery Novel. I'll always remember getting “The Call”. I could tell she was as happy to tell me as I was to receive the news. I'll always hear that merry voice. Peace to her and her family.

    • /blog Mike Shatzkin

      Thanks for posting this, Gerrie. I'm glad you got your own personal

      interaction with Ruth!

      Mike

  • Kadgall

    Thank you, Mike. You probably don't know this, but whenever I describe you to anyone, I always say you are the nicest person I've ever met. Funny that now I'm reading the story of the person you gave that moniker to. No doubt you learned many of your genuine ways from Ruth.
    I never met Ruth but it sure sounds like I would have loved to have had. I love to read your blog, but definitely enjoy your personal stories best of all. You really know how to write a wonderful tribute. Thanks for sharing Ruth's life story with your added personal touch.

    • /blog Mike Shatzkin

      I didn't know that. But I can definitely tell you that I've received both

      goads and inspirations in that direction all my life. My amazing wife, for

      example, provides both. Ruth was all inspiration; no goads.

      Patience and acceptance are definitely traits that, at least in my case,

      have been acquired with the passage of time. By the time you met me I was

      50. You might not have said the same thing when I was 30 (which was about

      when Martha started working on me.)

      Mike

      • Kadgall

        I was going to write: “No doubt you learned many of your genuine ways from Ruth (and Martha).” But I left the Martha part out. I am always amazed at Martha's genuine spirit. I still vividly remember her stopping and REALLY talking to a sad homeless woman on the street. It wasn't a 'put hand in your pocket and give her loose change' kind of moment. It was a, 'give her money and 10 minutes of my time' type of moment. I learned a lot that day too. I am more aware of myself and my attention span now especially when around people who are less fortunate than myself now, because of Martha. You're a lucky man!

      • /blog Mike Shatzkin

        It won't surprise you to hear that Ruth really loved Martha too!

        Mike

  • Janet Laurence

    I am so sad to hear of Ruth Cavin's death. I met her when St Martin's bought the US rights to some of my Darina Lisle books. Alas, they didn't make much of a dent in the US consciousness but Ruth was a great support. It was great to meet up with her in Gijon for Semana Negra and other conferences. I always hoped to be able to get back on her editing list! Thank you for filling in so much of her background. Ruth was unforgettable and a wonderful person JANET LAURENCE

    • /blog Mike Shatzkin

      Thanks, Janet, for checking in here as yet another writer who loved working

      with Ruth!

      Mike

  • http://johnaustinblog.blogspot.com John R. Austin

    Mike,
    What a wonderful and warm remembrance of someone so dear to you, your family and the publishing profession.
    Ruth must have been an exceptional person and I thank you for sharing a little bit of her life with me…

    • /blog Mike Shatzkin

      Thanks, John. As you can see, this post has attracted a large number of

      comments. I've had quite a few offline too. Ruth had a lot of friends!

      Mike

  • Steven Womack

    Twenty years ago, Ruth Cavin edited my first three books with St. Martin's Thomas Dunne imprint. I'll always remember her as a kind, nurturing editor who loved writers, loved working with them, and really enjoyed socializing at writers conferences. She'll be missed.
    Steven Womack

    • /blog Mike Shatzkin

      Thanks, Steven. I can assure you that Ruth loved socializing at every

      opportunity, writers conferences and anyplace else. She could hang out,

      smoke cigarettes, and shoot the bull with the best of them! I'm glad she

      stopped smoking in her early 80s or she might have died at 91!

      Mike

  • marytod

    Your story about Ruth Cavin is very timely for me personally because it shows that coming late to a new career can be wonderfully productive. As someone who began writing fiction as a second career, I am truly inspired! Thanks, Mike.

    • /blog Mike Shatzkin

      I can tell you for sure that your comment would have made Ruth feel *very*

      good!

      Mike

  • Olinecog

    Lovely post. My sympathies on the loss of your friend. — Oline Cogdill

  • http://www.warrenmurphy.com warren murphy

    Sadly, never my editor; thankfully, always my friend. Ruth Cavin was a one-off. I remember last her sending me a book for a blurb. “Couldn't get anybody on your A-list?” I suggested. She said, “I've decided to reach out for the Caveman audience.” Later, I told her that the book had saved my life; she said she would forgive the author anyway. There was nobody, remotely, like her. — warren murphy

    • /blog Mike Shatzkin

      Thanks for the samples from Ruth's droll side. She had all kinds of wit!

      Mike

  • Pingback: A Passing Noted | Notes from Low Places

  • http://itsallmaya.com Lynn

    What a beautiful tribute to a lady that I have never met, but the love that I can feel through your word, makes me wish that I had had the privilege to know her even half as well as you have.

    I'm sure she's smiling at you and I'm sure you count yourself blessed for having had her in your life!

  • Thorsonsusan

    Ditto on “marytod”'s comment below. What an inspiration! Thanks for sharing this.

  • Eileendreyer

    I don't know anyone in the mystery community who didn't adore Ruth. I never got to work with her, but I shared many a conference. She was truly one of a kind.

    • /blog Mike Shatzkin

      Thanks. The mystery community got a lot of time to know Ruth. I'd have bet a

      lot of it loved her.

      Mike

  • danbloom

    Mike,

    Being out of the USA for 20 years in Asia, I had mever come across Ruth Cavin's name or work before until I read a nice obit in the Jewish Telegraphic Agency news site the other day and wanting to know about the amazing woman i googled and found the NYT obit and then David Rothman in DC sent me a link to your post here which I read today in Taiwan. What a lovely lovely lovely story and so well told. Not only did Ruth live a wonder-full life, but she had many many friends along the way, it is obvious, and the comments here were part of the draw for me as well. I printed the entire post and comments out and read it over two times. That she worked all her adult life until the very end, and that her boss and publishers kept her on all the way into her 80s and early 90s, this story deserves a front page NYT story and a book about her. Maybe as part of her memoir. I don't know anybody here, but glad i found your post today in far away Far East. Ruth's life resonates. Thanks for posting this. — danny bloom

    • /blog Mike Shatzkin

      Thanks for the note, Dan. Ruth did get her obit in the New York Times. Not

      front page, but very decent coverage. As for the movie, tell any film

      producers you meet that I'd be happy to discuss it with them!

      Mike

  • Lindajuneoromrod

    Ruth was certainly an amazing women and yes you are right she always had an amazing smile on her face. I will miss you Ruth at our holidays parties at the Shatzkins. I am so glad I got to see you at Thanksgiviing.

    Linda

    • /blog Mike Shatzkin

      Thanks for checking in, Linda. Holidays without Ruth will not be the same.

      Mike

  • http://www.katherine-hall-page.org Katherine Hall Page

    I've just finishing working on this snowy, (yet again) gray day in New England and went to check if there was anything more about Ruth. The warmth of your wonderful tribute, and all the comments, is palpable!
    My first mystery was the first book Ruth acquired when she went to SMP from Walker in 1988. We went on to so five more together before I very reluctantly left for Morrow. She had become a dear friend and I knew it was for life, which helped make the decision. Among many great memories is a great lunch with Ruth and Frances at Ruth's favorite Periyali. Much laughter, and I just sat back and listened to these two very smart ladies.
    I spoke to Sally Richardson and there seems to be a possibility of a memorial service in the city at some point. I hope so. Want to hear more stories and be with people who miss her the way I do.
    Thank you.
    Katherine Hall Page

    • /blog Mike Shatzkin

      It has been so touching to read the tributes to Ruth in the comment stream

      here and in other places on the net. There is a website run by some writers

      that carried a great personal memory with a long comment string. (Sorry I

      don't have the link to hand…)

      Of course, Ruth had a vast network of friends and admirers. And I agree that

      some sort of tribute in New York just has to happen. I'm sure it will.

      Mike

      • http://www.katherine-hall-page.org Katherine Hall Page

        If you hear, please let me know, and vice versa.
        Best wishes,
        Katherine

  • Pingback: I Want to Believe, But … « Debbi Mack: My Life on the Mid-List